Well apparently thats what I did wrong. I have had several dobies and Shilow is the first one that has had this wide of range of whinning, moaning, and what I call just flat out arguing with you. Do you have any additional ideas to help stop this ?Some whining is normal. However, you can easily end up teaching them to whine if you pay attention to them while they do it, unintentionally rewarding it.
I find Shanoa's whining supremely annoying, and if it goes on too long I will usually crate her.