Doberman Forum : Doberman Breed Dog Forums banner

More Curiosity

1580 Views 27 Replies 23 Participants Last post by  lyngr
2
I want to jump on the "Curiosity" thread bandwagon and expand it a little. In lieu of the changing legislation on docking and cropping in the country and abroad, I was wondering how these changes effect people's desire to own dobes. Would you stay with the breed if cropping and docking become illegal?

:emo6:

I will start by saying I would own a dobe no matter if it were cropped or docked. Don't get me wrong, I *do* love the cropped and docked look.






But, it is the "entire" dog I fell in love with and not just the look. I love the intelligence, attitude, and loyalty (not to mention--snuggles, kisses, smiles and crazies) that this breed brings. So, if I had my druthers, I would have pointy ears and nub. But if push comes to shove (which I hope it never does here) I will always have a dobe. I find it hard to think about any other breed in my life right now.
See less See more
1 - 20 of 28 Posts
Well push has come to shove in this country and it will not change my outlook on this breed one iota.
I would have to agree with you. While I LOVE the crop/docked enhancement. I Know the unaltered look would grow on me. In fact the more I see them on here, they more I'm liking them. The Doberman will always be a Dobermen, rather cropping/docking is done or not. But if push ever came to shove with these laws passing, I would side with the choice is yours to make.
Even though I prefer the c/d look, I would still own a dobe wether or not it was c/d.

I hope it never becomes a legal issue here but if it does, oh well with or without floppy ears and wagging tail it is still a dobe and that is all that matters to me:biggrin55
I also love the look of the c/d dobes BUT after owning 3 and loving 3 all different dobes, 1 natural ear/docked, 1 cropped and docked and 1 completely natural I realize it is the breed that I'm in love with. Don't get me wrong, I think they are all beautiful and love the looks of them either way but just like I couldn't marry a georgeous man without the personality to match and expect it to last a lifetime, I couldn't add a dog to my family for looks alone either.
2
Back in the 1970's, the first Dobe I fell in-love with was a Red uncropped/docked female.

I would own this breed regardless. The wiggle butt would definitely change without having the nub back there......I love that nub. Ears don't matter either way with me. I do like the cropped look, though and hope to have a cropped/docked dobe one day.


I just love this look......but, love the personality more!

See less See more
Back in the 1970's, the first Dobe I fell in-love with was a Red uncropped/docked female.

I would own this breed regardless. The wiggle butt would definitely change without having the nub back there......I love that nub. Ears don't matter either way with me. I do like the cropped look, though and hope to have a cropped/docked dobe one day.


I just love this look......but, love the personality more!

Rudi pics! I love them. He is too photogenic.:sunglasse
  • Like
Reactions: 1
My first Dobie experience was with my Aunts uncropped male, next my Father-in-laws female with cropped but not standing ears. Then I got my Bigelow....a Dobie/Weim mix. He was 100# Red Goofball....uncropped and Undocked~so funny and cute! And now I have my Petey....If I could have...his ears would be natural, but I love his docked butt! After owning Bigelow...I know their tails can be weapons! I love Dobermans in all shapes sizes and altered...or not!


Carol & Petey
i must say the doberman looks JUST to perfect with the ears cropped tail docked, you can take that away from them but not the personailty or the reputation they hold!!!! but ye i am pretty sad because of the law but in saying that, it is for the dobermans benefit... Unless someone can state otherwise????
I don't think I would abandon the breed, but I would possibly be more open to other breeds as well. The absolute breathtaking beauty of a cropped and docked Doberman on full alert would be only a memory and I think that would be sad. I don't dislike natural ears - my first one had them, but I just feel a flutter in my heart when I look at a fully alert Doberman as the founder of the breed intended them to look.

The first time I saw a fully natural Doberman I did a real double take, but as I've seen them more often (mostly in pictures), I don't mind it so much. I still want my cropped and docked Dobes, and always will.

I would really miss this look:

See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
3
Although I didn't always feel this way....I am to the point now that

This


This


or This


...they are all dobermans to me. If cropping were banned tommorrow (and I hope that it never is, because I think that people should be able to decide what they want) but I would still own dobes either way.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I don't want to get too political or too religious here......
Two facts.....
Docking is done when a pup is just a few days old and the tail is still cartilage, not bone.
Circumcision is done (mostly, depending on religion) when a boy is just a few days old.

If one is outlawed, how can the other still be legal? One could argue medical reasons for both......sanitary/infections vs. tail splitting.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I am starting to really like the tails :) Either way I would countinue to share my world with one. I love the c/d look as well as the a la natural look. I too hope that they do not ban it here, I still think it should be a personal choice.
I would still have a doberman. I like the c/d but its the inside package that really counts.:)
Part of what originally drew me to dobes was their look, but what has made me stay are their personalities. So regardless of what they look like now, I'm hooked!
I want to jump on the "Curiosity" thread bandwagon and expand it a little. In lieu of the changing legislation on docking and cropping in the country and abroad, I was wondering how these changes effect people's desire to own dobes. Would you stay with the breed if cropping and docking become illegal?

:emo6:

I will start by saying I would own a dobe no matter if it were cropped or docked. Don't get me wrong, I *do* love the cropped and docked look.






But, it is the "entire" dog I fell in love with and not just the look. I love the intelligence, attitude, and loyalty (not to mention--snuggles, kisses, smiles and crazies) that this breed brings. So, if I had my druthers, I would have pointy ears and nub. But if push comes to shove (which I hope it never does here) I will always have a dobe. I find it hard to think about any other breed in my life right now.
Nice pictures of Cole DobeMom616!! My opinion has changed since I have lived with a Doberman. Originally I probably would have gone with another breed if we could no longer dock for sure, crop maybe. Now after knowing the breed I would say it would not matter to me. Although, as long as we can I will alway's have a cropped and docked because that is my preference.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
CANNOT imagine life without Java's nub digging into the top of my foot as she sits on it! But I'd love her natural or cropped, even though I love the cropped look. (Dropped my furry child off at vet/boarding since I'll be away for son's graduation weekend. This house is far too quiet without her.)
I will love them no matter what. I would prefer them to be at least docked, but if that is not an option then so be it.

To me it would be like not loving my husband anymore if his hair fell out.....LOL, he would still be the same guy........just less hair :)
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Great question. I love the look of a c/d dobie but I have to say that I love the look of any doberman. I am so addicted that I could not imagine not having one. :)
In order of Preference:
1. docked and cropped
2. not cropped, but docked, there would be no adjustment
3. I really think it would take awhile for me to get used to the tail being there , I love the nub. It is just to cute. No offence to anyone I just don't like the tail left natural at all.
1 - 20 of 28 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top