I always knew dobermans were smart but sometimes they really impress me. I feed my macaw a chicken wing with his dinner every night and I always give GKar one. We have a 6 year old red female living with us so she also gets one if she lays quietly and waits. Anyway, I only had two pieces left tonight so I told GKar that there was not enough for everyone to have one so only Beevis, the bird would get one. He looked at me for a minute then looked over at Tani, the female, walked over to her and made her leave the room. Then he came back and looked at me again saying "Ok, I got rid of her there's enough now". I did not give him one but I did give them both new chewwy. I tend to talk to my animals a lot but I never believed they listened.