Doberman Forum : Doberman Breed Dog Forums banner
1 - 20 of 23 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
4,856 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)

· Banned
Joined
·
6,744 Posts
Nice attention! His sit looked straight too, Rommel does the "I need to lean away from you so I can look at you" thing too :D I cant spit food for the life of me though, I used the Ivan method with him instead. Rah looks great though!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,856 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
i swear to god rah caught the cheese EVERY other video but this one :) but in one video the clinic cat makes an appearance, in another i hit a chair, and in ONE video rah missd every piece i spit.

i am going to need another leash soon at this rate. rah is hard on leashes!

and yes, rah's lean away to see your face - its worse with the boobs too, he has to see around them :) and heavens forbid i wear a hoodie sweatshirt with food in the pockets :)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,593 Posts
awww great job! me and duchess need to learn how to reliably spit and catch...she does great with the food in the mouth...but no so great on catching...lol so it disrupts us. but yeah its worth it once she will get better at catching :) he looks like such a great boy!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,619 Posts
He does a super job! It's funny how he chose that moment to miss the cheese, LOL
He really is a beautiful boy :)

Orson will watch me and pay close attention with 'in the house heel' the moment we set foot outside it is all over, he barely wants to walk without pulling!
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
9,177 Posts
He is really coming along! I think your matching green scrub shirt and booties are really so fashionable - LOL!!

I spit hot dogs too - my trainer had never done that before and couldn't believe it when she saw me doing it............. I like her a lot, but really NEED a trainer who does more competition..........no one close though so I make do.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,023 Posts
Wow he is so big and yes very good lookin' - definitely would not want to meet him in a dark alley. His heeling looks very nice as does his turns.

The only problem that I have seen in alot of dogs when food is used this way consistently, great for when first teaching the watch command, is that unless the handlers timing is really great - the dog is rewarded when in the incorrect position. It tends to cause sign tracking as well (as does a toy placed under the armpit) - which in turns causes forging or crowding of the handler (not seeing this at all with these two, great job) . But when the handler uses spitting food to inititally teach the command and then switches to a verbal praise (Good watch) or as the case may be a correction (No Watch) and then a release command (Okay, Free) before rewarding it changes the whole picture and it's easier (for the handler) to reward for correctness and the dog to know exactly what will earn him his reward. Just a thought for those doing competition.
 

· Registered
1
Joined
·
8,076 Posts
Yes I will be doing comp. with *******. I am trying to practise without food. So far so good, but it comes a point where she will stop the eye contact and just want the bait. So I give it to her...how do I work through this???
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,023 Posts
The key is that YOU stop BEFORE she looses her focus. Free her and play with her/reward her. Best to not let her decide when she is done - rewarding her is only rewarding the incorrect behavior leading her to believe that she really is not required to keep focus when you want her to, only when she wants to and if you are doing competition you don't want her deciding when she is "done". Each day, or if you do short session several times a day, just add a little more time that she is required to keep the focus - I use counting my steps or measuring distance to keep track. No doubt this method takes longer but in the long run it is well worth it as you are not tricking the dog to look in the general direction of your eyes (ie., armpit, mouth etc) and bad habits don't develop as easily.

The most important thing that I learned (the hard way I might add) is not talking to my dog along the way.....tell her she is good a few times, just in a normal tone while your walking. Seems most handlers have no difficulties telling a dog when they are wrong...they tend to forget to praise along the way. When I say good to my girl, she knows that she is correct and struts her stuff - also knowing that a reward is not to far off in her future.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,856 Posts
Discussion Starter · #17 ·
velmadobe said:
He is really coming along! I think your matching green scrub shirt and booties are really so fashionable - LOL!!
my tech for the day also had the green scrubs (full set) so we were quite a set!

Lexus said:
Very cool video Kim! LOL, I do the same happy play reward with Lex of grab the leash :D

Very nice to see the rah-man in action!
thats actually sedate for him - he typically pulls me almost off my feet and goes for a lOOOOONG time (its how we made it through agility class). but thanks ;)

K9Jarko said:
Wow he is so big and yes very good lookin' - definitely would not want to meet him in a dark alley. His heeling looks very nice as does his turns.

The only problem that I have seen in alot of dogs when food is used this way consistently, great for when first teaching the watch command, is that unless the handlers timing is really great - the dog is rewarded when in the incorrect position. It tends to cause sign tracking as well (as does a toy placed under the armpit) - which in turns causes forging or crowding of the handler (not seeing this at all with these two, great job) . But when the handler uses spitting food to inititally teach the command and then switches to a verbal praise (Good watch) or as the case may be a correction (No Watch) and then a release command (Okay, Free) before rewarding it changes the whole picture and it's easier (for the handler) to reward for correctness and the dog to know exactly what will earn him his reward. Just a thought for those doing competition.
well, thanks for the comments, except im not sure where you get that "food is used this way consistently" - my dog is trained for food, physical and verbal praise, tug, fetch, stuffy toys, and even just a raise of my eyebrow or a smile from me (yes, that is a reward for them when we work, i can communicate with those methods without saying a word and no judge can mark me off for that!). is he working for food in this video? yes, for part of it - if you notice, he also got rewarded with a pat (or maybe that was the other video, where i grabbed his face and smushed it), he got rewarded with tug at least twice and being allowed to jump up on me, and if you can hear the sound (im not sure google video transmits the sounds, to be honest), im also telling him what a good man he is when hes looking at me and for one of the awesome turns he had where his hind end completely tracked. do i use food? absolutely - hes very food motivated and he learned a finish in 4 tries using food. what i dont have here is a clicker, which allows me extremely precise timing whenever i need it - however this isnt a teaching session, this is using behaviors that he already knows - i dont click for this anymore - he gets one (food) reward at the end of completed behavior. i do click still for fast sits when we work on speed with accuracy. i never click his platz as its a default behavior now, but he gets rewarded in other ways for a platz.

my dog isnt watching my mouth, he isnt watching my hand, he isnt tracking my hands as they move (i can heel with either my hand against my stomach as proper for the AKC ring or with the arm swinging as i will need for bite sport). he is pure and simple making eye contact with me - the same eye contact i ask for and reinforce when hes in a front, when hes fussing, when hes in stationary attention, when we are "ready" when he is in his stays, etc. eye contact is above all the most reinforced behavior this dog has, and yes it started with clicking - the minute he looked at me, i clicked. i can hold cookies, toys, you name it, out in my hands and he watches my eyes - because reinforcement only comes when you do what i want - which is LOOK at me. spitting food isnt used in teaching a command - its used to reinforce a final behavior because i dont like holding food in my hands and its easier.

in addition, i never ask for a watch. i have no word for "watch me". i say his name, and he looks at me. its default. i will correct say his name to regain lost attention if he is distracted, if he looks away he is rewarded the minute he looks back. i rewarded for 1, 2, 5, 10 seconds - and increased the time. he rarely NEEDS a crrection for this behavior, buut i will use a short pop once he understands what the pop means. but right now, he doesnt need it.

this dog is 90% positively trained by both my competition obedience trainer and his bitesport trainer when we have worked with him (a third private trainer who is very well known specifically within the dobe community, is less positive but has similar methods - rah responded well to him as well, but at this point it is my choice to focus on training him positively until he NEEDS the corrections).
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,023 Posts
Sorry Doberkim...did not mean to sound like I was talking about your dog just dogs I have seen in general. I did say that your dog does not have those problems at all and actually looked really good in my original post. Was just talking in general - clicker training is very similiar to the type of training I use and it's great that you've never used compulsion I definitely applaud that....I don't use compulsion either.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,856 Posts
Discussion Starter · #19 ·
no problem, im proud of how he looks for how little we have trained - hes only 1 week into being actively pushed for anything, after a few months off.

im not against compulsion and i will use it -but only when needed. i dont train with it, though.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,023 Posts
That is very impressive that he's had so much "time off" and performs that well. I truly believe his performance and willingness to perform after all that time has to do with how you imprinted him, all motivational, to begin with.

I agree also that compulsion is not a bad thing and may eventually be needed to "fine tune" a dog for competition. Sadly, I have seen more then my share of handlers in Schutzhund (usually old school handlers) who teach the basics using compulsion - forced downs etc., it disgusts me to no end. Correcting a dog BEFORE he truly understands/learns what the command or action is - is just wrong in my book. To each their own though.......
 
1 - 20 of 23 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top